AI and Buy Now, Pay Later: Revolutionizing Holiday Shopping for Small Businesses

Holiday Shopping Transformed: The Rise of AI and BNPL

The holiday shopping season is rapidly approaching, and small business owners are preparing to adapt to new consumer expectations. This year, artificial intelligence (AI) and Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) are changing the landscape—promising both opportunities and challenges for merchants seeking to maximize sales during this crucial time. According to PayPal’s 2025 Holiday Shopping Survey, a staggering 40% of American shoppers used AI for their purchases in the last year, with 77% of them planning to leverage AI tools again this holiday season.

Understanding the Impact of AI on Consumer Behavior

The findings of this survey reveal a critical shift in shopping habits. Shoppers are engaging with AI to navigate product choices effectively, indicating a demand for visibility across AI-powered platforms. Notably, 34% use AI to hunt for the best deals, while 30% rely on it for product comparisons. Small businesses must optimize their product presentations to remain competitive in this digitally driven marketplace.

Buy Now, Pay Later: A Game-Changer for Merchants

Alongside AI, the adoption of BNPL services is reshaping consumer spending dynamics. With 50% of shoppers planning to use BNPL this holiday season, the method has become a standard expectation. The appeal lies in its promise of affordability and budget control; 52% of consumers are more likely to purchase when this payment option is available. Merchants offering BNPL can see a significant boost—averaging a 91% increase in order value for enterprises and 62% for small businesses, showcasing the financial benefits of adopting this flexible payment method.

Implementing AI and BNPL: Considerations for Small Businesses

While integrating AI and BNPL brings notable advantages, small businesses also face unique challenges. It's essential for these entrepreneurs to invest in crafting a robust online presence and ensuring their offerings resonate with AI algorithms. Moreover, adopting BNPL could require partnerships with financial service providers, which may add an additional layer of complexity and cost. Thoughtful marketing strategies must ensure that this payment option is prominently displayed throughout the consumer journey.

The Importance of Omnichannel Shopping Experiences

The survey highlights a revival in omnichannel retailing; 64% of shoppers intend to make purchases in-store this holiday season. This trend emphasizes the necessity for small businesses to create seamless shopping experiences across both digital and physical platforms. Engaging customers with rewards programs can enhance loyalty, as evidenced by 74% of consumers preferring to shop with merchants who offer cashback or rewards.

Conclusion: The Path Forward for Small Businesses

As the holiday season nears, small business owners must pivot quickly to meet changing consumer preferences. Those who can create a unified shopping experience, integrate AI and BNPL options, and foster meaningful customer interactions will stand to benefit not just from the holiday rush, but achieve long-term growth. Equipped with knowledge on implementing these strategies, now is the time for small businesses to act.

Learn How to Invest Smarter — Free Info, No Obligation, Nationwide Support.